The top Windows Phone 7 app -- YouTube -- is just a website shortcut

After installing and eagerly clicking the icon I was greeted with... m.youtube.com. Yes, the YouTube app is a shortcut to the built-in Web browser. No more, no less... just a shortcut.
I suppose you could say that this is the first smartphone Web app -- but really, it's just laziness. Incidentally, did you know that Windows Phone 7 also lacks a Windows Live Messenger app? Maybe there's a Web-based client that I can use instead..
[via @ryan, and others]












Comments
27
Subscribe to commentsJasonDashNov 13th 2010 8:54PM
Just for clarification, although it's just a shortcut to the app, it does install the plugin to actually watch youtube videos, which sin't there natively :P Although yeah, in all fairness, it's a bit of a cheat :L
Ah, by the who, there is a Windows Live Messenger app - it's called Messenger by Miyowa. It's passable, not great.
arashNov 14th 2010 12:03AM
Yeah really didn't expect something like this from downloadsquad, they could at least call josh at engadget to check, if you dont install youtube app you cant watch youtube videos, and if you download it you can, theres also other youtube apps for WP7 in marketplace which will work like just any other youtube apps but they still need this first youtube app(the plugin) to be installed
Sebastian AnthonyNov 14th 2010 5:36AM
Why does it need a 'plug-in'?
WP7 ships with Flash, right?
Sebastian AnthonyNov 14th 2010 5:40AM
Ah, I see now -- a plug-in to allow you to watch them in the native video player. I wonder what codec WP7 is missing...
I saw the Messenger app, but I've heard it's not great. You'd think that Live Messenger, as one of the biggest services on the planet, would get its own launch app...!
Rupert Madden-AbbottNov 13th 2010 9:07PM
Just out of interest, from a person who is yet to acquire a smartphone, what kind of functionality would a native Youtube app give you that you couldn't get from a web app?
gonintendoNov 13th 2010 9:49PM
nothing and 9 times out of 10 the youtube mobile site has more features and is better organized. (and google can update it at will)
Rupert Madden-AbbottNov 13th 2010 9:53PM
Just out of interest, from a person who is yet to acquire a smartphone, what kind of functionality would a native Youtube app give you that you couldn't get from a web app?
morganNov 14th 2010 2:59AM
gonintendo is exactly right, it's sometimes a bad assumption that an 'app' will have more features or do something the mobile site itself won't. That's often not the case, and it means the app features usually lag the site itself, and sometimes lose support for a while, like with Facebook on the iPhone.
The entire app thing is sort of out there because of Apple, but really the more people use mobile sites the better to avoid a ton of platform fragmentation and orphaned apps over time.
Sebastian AnthonyNov 14th 2010 5:38AM
I was thinking along the lines of the Leanback remote control -- though, admittedly, that could all be done with a Web app too.
johnnyNov 13th 2010 9:16PM
Youtube app by Lazyworm, full featured youtube app using windows phone 7 UI. Works great
Rupert Madden-AbbottNov 13th 2010 9:54PM
Just out of interest, from a person who is yet to acquire a smartphone, what kind of functionality would a native Youtube app give you that you couldn't get from a web app?
Christian WilliamsonNov 13th 2010 11:18PM
yeah it installs the player plugin into the native video player as well.
and for the record, the player itself works 10000% times better than the one on android. this thing uses google services in a better way than my last droid did.
wp7 rocks
SilverWaveNov 14th 2010 3:51AM
heh but does it copy n paste?
LOL
Lameware
SilverWaveNov 14th 2010 4:19AM
The lamrphone7 certainly has the same feature set ;-)
Christian WilliamsonNov 14th 2010 5:14AM
Protip: People reading these replies remember, supervise your children when they are on the internet.
now....
silver.
I think I understand the point you were trying to make even though it is mostly incomprehensable. Firstly, copy and paste are coming before December 31st. That puts copy and paste as well as multitasking on the table 2 months after WP7 launch. Given that it took apple more than 2 years to bring that to the table, thats a pretty heafty accomplishment.
Now while you might obviouslly have an android phone, I did too. In fact, I had 4 of them. 3 of them died within a month, the last one lasted about a year. Droid 1 at launch. So I'm well aware of what the phone does and doesnt have. I used it for a year. I rooted it. Ran Bugless Beast, Ultimate Droid, among 3 or 4 others. It's true, they have the same feature set, but so does the iphone, webos, symbian, and blackberry os for the most part. So I'm not exactly what point you were trying to drive home with that. But what came out of your fingers when pressed against the keyboard was "The phone has an operating system". Good job. Way to state the obvious.
My beef with the android os is that sure, it promises a lot. But the implementation from all vendors has been slow, laggy and unresponsive. Not one of them have good cameras. Most are slow and unresponsive. Try taking an action picture at a sporting event for example. Thats a feat not one of them can handle. The apps are all basically web site front ends. The games, lets see the 2 that are decent are on every other phone platform under the sun (comon do we really need angry birds on EVERYTHING?). It's an laughable mobile gaming platform. The droid X is great for the 4 hours the battery lasts. I could go on and on. The one thing the droid "Does" well, is be a gps. Thats it. Turn by Turn directions is coming to WP7 as well within 3 months. Even without it, the bing maps and direction features they implemented are already so good, I almost dont care (live traffic updates right on the default map app, something i needed a second app for on my droid). My new focus runs great, fast as hell, super responsive, fantastic gaming with the xbox live integration, with (according to most mobile developers) the best dev tools and support for a mobile platform on the market. I'm happy, ive had both, and I like my focus better. Most people that bought the phone came from other smartphones and we pretty much all agree on this point.
Now lastly kiddo. I saw you there trying to use some pretty 1337 words there. lamr, yeah thats cute. But wait, didnt people stop using that one like i dunno, 99, 2000, 01? Feeling nostalgic or are you just behind on what the jr. high kids are using on facebook these days? Wow, and I thought I was out of touch.
It's cute that youre trying though. I think most of us down deep, think you little newbies are adorable after a while, I guess you grow on us over time.
Keep working on the posting though. You almost did it all in English this time! Way to go!
SilverWaveNov 14th 2010 6:45AM
@Christian Williamson (aka ms apologist)
> Firstly, copy and paste are coming before December 31st.
D'oh so you agree that's a failing and that you get a lamephone till then... OK.
>That puts copy and paste as well as multitasking on the table 2 months after WP7 launch. Given that it took apple more than 2 years to bring that to the table, thats a pretty heafty accomplishment.
So your argument is that the lamephone7 is 2 years out of date? OK.
> In fact, I had 4 of them. 3 of them died within a month, the last one lasted about a year. Droid 1 at launch. So I'm well aware of what the phone does and doesnt have. I used it for a year. I rooted it. Ran Bugless Beast, Ultimate Droid, among 3 or 4 others.
Poor little rich boy :P the phones are probable reacting badly to all that acne cream and your bad body odour ;-)
>My beef with the android os is [...] I could go on and on.
Yes you do!
>The one thing the droid "Does" well, is be a gps. Thats it. Turn by Turn directions is coming to WP7 as well within 3 months. Even without it, the bing maps [blah blah blah]
fanboi
Now lastly kiddo. I saw you there trying to use some pretty 1337 words there. lamr, yeah thats cute.
LOL or I typed "r" instead or "e" heh. I think this can be filled under transference :-)
https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Transference
>Wow, and I thought I was out of touch.
Agreed, you are granddad.
>It's cute [blah] newbies [blah] adorable...
see previous link to on transference
Final advise: its been fun but you need to look up the definition of troll ;-)
"Ha-ha!"
burnblueNov 13th 2010 11:31PM
Uh.. That top Marketplace app is plugin, allowing you to watch YouTube videos on the phone. I can see how regular buyers might not have realized this, but you'd think a DownloadSquad writer might know
Anyway, if you're looking for a browsing and searching client then you want "YouTube by LazyWorm". I agree that Google's efforts on WP7 have been lacking, but I guess they weren't going to get a lot of early access to the OS, being a competitor
KangaNov 14th 2010 12:06AM
In its first week on sale in the United States, Windows Phone 7 has been a sales flop.
Farting Dino is also listed in its best seller list. Yeah, such apps are on all platforms, but only on Windows Phone 7 is it one of their best sellers.
KeegdnaBNov 14th 2010 12:31AM
troll troll is troll
SilverWaveNov 14th 2010 4:04AM
I'm expecting the lamephone7 to last longer than the lamephonekin...
heh