FrostWire for Android brings quick, slick P2P file sharing to your phone
Until now, there hasn't been a true peer-to-peer application for Android, or indeed any smartphone. There are a slew of helper apps, like the excellent Transdroid, but their main purpose is to allow remote, on-the-move management of your installed-at-home BitTorrent and Gnutella clients. FrostWire is different: it brings P2P transfers to your phone -- yes, FrostWire shares ringtones, camera photos, music and apps that are stored on your phone.FrostWire for Android is just for phone-to-phone transfers, too. Despite there being an excellent desktop version of FrostWire, the Android version doesn't seem to search the same network. Perhaps that's a good thing, though: do you really want to download 700MB movies over 3G? It is quite fun to download photos from other people's phones, however...
First off, I should warn you that I haven't tried FrostWire over a cellular network -- I honestly don't know how well it would perform, or even whether mobile operators allow peer-to-peer transfers over their networks. I used my local Wi-Fi network and it worked well -- but even then, some transfers refused to start. Basically, FrostWire has all of P2P's usual problems -- and probably a few more!

Setup
When you first install FrostWire (grab the free version if you don't want to spend $5 on the Market), the first thing you're asked to do is provide a nickname, and select which file types you want to share. There is no folder/directory selection, so be careful! If you select 'pictures', every JPG, GIF and PNG on your phone will be shared with the world.You have the choice of sharing Pictures, Videos, Applications, Documents, Music and Ringtones. I wouldn't suggest you share everything, but it's up to you.

Searching & Chat
Finding stuff to download is as simple as on the desktop: either click a peer and pore through their files, or hit 'search' at the top and type something in. There weren't a whole lot of peers online when I did my testing (20 or so), but there was plenty of stuff to download, from pictures to ringtones, TV episodes to applications. As FrostWire for Android grows, I am sure you'll be able to find just about anything.
FrostWire for Android also has chat functionality built-in, if you feel like chatting... about stuff. There's a global chat room (which would no doubt be unusable with thousands of peers), and you can also send private messages. During testing no one returned my private messages, though, so I have no idea if they actually work.

Downloading
Here's the rub: ultimately, you're only going to get decent download speeds if you and the other peer are using Wi-Fi on a decent Internet connection. If the uploading peer is on 3G -- or 2G! -- it feels almost like Napster with a dial-up modem.
Still, files on mobile phones tend to be small -- ringtones, music, photos and apps are only a megabyte or two each -- so it rarely takes that long to download a file with FrostWire.
Conclusion
No matter which way I look at it, I can't see FrostWire as anything other than the first serious piracy app for Android. There will be those that claim there are valid, legal uses of FrostWire... but other than voyeuristically sharing photos, I can't see any.
I'm also uncertain that cellular peer-to-peer is ready for prime-time. If the American mobile network is already struggling to keep up with demand, imagine what the crushing force of peer-to-peer traffic would do!
FrostWire for Android Tech Specs
- Installed Size -- 700KB
- Speed/Responsiveness -- Nippy, could not discover any slow-downs (Android 2.1 @ 600 MHz, LG GT540)
- User Interface -- Not fantastic, but easy enough to learn -- it's a very simple app, after all
- Configurability & Extensibility -- Lots of network configuration available -- but I still don't see why you would use this app on your home network... and you can't control your mobile operator's network setup!
- License -- Free, open source, but it costs $5 from the Android Market (free download here)













Comments
17
Subscribe to commentsouriel.ohayonNov 1st 2010 10:28AM
Please ignore previous comment, which was automatically inserted from 1password (no idea why)
just wanted to notify that the app says on their page that you can pay if you want, but i don t see any other option to get the app for free as claimed
Sebastian AnthonyNov 1st 2010 10:30AM
You see the ginormous 'FREE DOWNLOAD' banner at the top, right?
ouriel.ohayonNov 1st 2010 10:34AM
Sebastien, i also See the Ginormous 4.99 USD price and buy button on the android market. please indicate how to get the app free.
Sebastian AnthonyNov 1st 2010 10:54AM
Huh?
Click one of the many links in my review. They all lead to the Android page on the FrostWire website.
If you need help, google for 'install APK android'
Ouriel OhayonNov 1st 2010 11:29AM
My bad, but their site is not very clear, indeed the link itself gets you to a free download but not the QR code > http://www.flickr.com/photos/ouriel/5136258678/
cybercapitalistNov 1st 2010 10:57AM
If your phone is able to install 3rd party apps (i.e. not from the Android Market), you can just visit the link in your phone's browser, download the APK from the "Free Download" link and install from there (I just did this).
GubatronNov 1st 2010 8:19PM
The application was built initially to share files locally on a Wi-Fi network. There's plenty of legal use in this respect. Take pictures, video and music from your phone and transfer it to a tablet, or your Google TV. Teachers and Students sharing files in campus, go to a conference and the speaker can share the powerpoint slides with the audience, and so on.
The application is not meant to run over 2G or 3G, it's stated clearly on the market, and the team has been very adamant about this since the start of the project, why? 1) Carrier Rules 2) Connections are too slow and unreliable and this would only hurt the network.
Maybe when 4G support is widely available and the carriers are ok with p2p FrostWire for Android will enable connectivity outside Wi-Fi.
Team FrostWire
Sebastian AnthonyNov 1st 2010 11:42AM
Hey Guba!
Could you describe an actual usage scenario, then? I struggle to imagine this app's utility on a Wi-Fi network.
In a coffee shop or something?
mmargelNov 1st 2010 12:59PM
There are actually Bit Torrent clients that will allow you to download P2P directly to your phone - not just control your PC client
Sebastian AnthonyNov 1st 2010 1:50PM
Got any names?
GubatronNov 1st 2010 8:19PM
@Sebastian Anthony
Here are several case uses we've envisioned for a long time. However, most of them will only come to fruition if the application's adoption rate is ubiquitous on all android phones.
0. Partying, dinner with friends. How many times have you gone out with friends, now everybody has smartphones with decent cameras but your friends are too lazy to email them or even put the pictures on facebook, maybe you'll see those pictures of that memorable night out 3 months later on facebook if you're lucky. With FrostWire, right after you finish party and you head out to eat a slice of pizza at 3am in the morning, usually every pizza/caffe/restaurant joint has open wi-fi, while you eat, instead of not talking to each other because you're texting or sending email (like it happens in many dinner tables across the world), you could all actually look at the screen of your phone while connecting to each other.
1. Cafe/Bar/Restaurant/Airports - If there's a Wi-Fi network that has a relaxed administration policy (no peer isolation, UDP broadcast enabled, UDP multicast enabled), then peers can connect and share.
When you look at the text box on the Chat, it says "Break the ice". We think the most social device that we have is our phone, but it's mostly thought of as a remote social interaction device (phone calls, email, etc). We thought that maybe we're not the only socially awkward people in the world, hey, if you have a smartphone nowadays probably you're a bit geekish and when you find your self in a room full of hundreds of people (say some tech event, party, etc) You're probably going to be wandering around eating the free food and looking at your phone, tweeting what you're doing.
We think these are great occassions for those of us that are super extroverted online but introverted in real life to connect to others, that's where the FrostWire for Android Chatroom kicks in. It's a great way to break the ice, and I can envision people in bars maybe even hooking up anonymously from their phones before making actual contact, browsing each other's pictures, checking their musical taste, etc.
2. Say there's no Wi-Fi hotspot around, but there's a powerful Android running 2.2. That Android could become the access point for phones around and they could connect. I envision for example people in NYC riding say the front or back cars of the train to see if they can hook up with strangers and exchange files.
3. A hipster Indie Band from Williamsburg making a break during the middle of the show in a bar, and taking out an android phone and saying, "If you guys have FrostWire, go ahead and download these demo tracks on my phone", bam.
4. The amount of videos and pictures I have of my baby daughter outweights the number of other files I have on my phone, I'm sure this is a reality for many parents with Android phones, and you can certainly download a lot of pictures and videos like this from other people. You need a way to share this content in a fast and convenient way, sometimes I dread thinking of looking for the USB cable, mounting, etc. I just want to copy the files to my wife's or my mom's phone, now they can download these pictures en-masse, I don't have to attach them and email them. This also gives you a great level of privacy, not everything should go through the internet, now it can be done at a personal level.
(Currently we're working on a mechanism to transfer files wirelessly from the phone to FrostWire for Desktop, so it'll be a great tool for syncing files wirelessly to your phone. That's another great legal use of both FrostWire for Android and FrostWire for desktop)
5. Podcasts. One thing people tend to carry on their mobile mp3 playback device is podcasts, do a search for podcast and you'll find tons of great podcasts, we think this is a a great legal use of p2p technology and it helps content creators save bandwidth. (We're working on tools to help podcasters distribute their podcasts without paying a dime in bandwidth as well)
As for the illegal use, we condemn illegal downloading, we think that in fact there's way more free content out there that needs to be discovered (count how many indie bands are in myspace, vs popular signed artists..., being popular on p2p is not easy either but we try to expose as much great content as possible), and that's why we have initiatives like FrostClick.com and promotions of Creative Contents material on FrostWire for desktop.
Also, I wanted to thank you for this review, we think it's actually the best so far (other than the conclusion on piracy, we're trying to get away from that bad shadow ever since we started the FrostWire project, we think P2P, as technologies like the tape, VHS, and CDs, has to mature and we all need to start looking at it from other perspectives than just P2P = Piracy, file sharing is only the beginning of what p2p can do)
Cheers
Sebastian AnthonyNov 1st 2010 2:02PM
OK, you've sold me :) Grand and very, very cool plans.
Sorry for the pessimistic conclusion. If only you'd said this on the FrostWire site... on the press release!
GubatronNov 1st 2010 8:19PM
Press Release updated!
http://frostwire.wordpress.com/2010/10/26/frostwire-for-android-hits-the-market-paying-is-optional/
Sebastian AnthonyNov 2nd 2010 9:30AM
There we go :) Very nice.
DillonNov 1st 2010 5:07PM
I just got the app so explain this in simple terms i have to be on the same wi fi network as someone else and they have to have the app and what im looking for ??
GubatronNov 18th 2010 10:34PM
If you want to share files with another android phone in front of you, you have to be on the same Wi-Fi network.
If you're all by yourself with no other androids then you'll want to have the application connect to the internet through the Wi-Fi network.
You'll be able to see others only if your Wi-FI router supports UPnP port forwarding or Manual port forwarding.
Once connected you will be able to browse the 25 closest peers and search the files of everybody connected to you and those 25 peers, and those 25 peers, and those 25 peers... theoretically your search could hit millions of phones and results will come back in less than a second if good network conditions apply.
You have absolute control of what's shared and what's not shared, you can also offer files to other users, either publicly on the chatroom, or in the form of a private message.
Very soon we'll offer integration between the desktop version and the android version so you can transfer files to your phone and back without an USB cable.
theampersandNov 1st 2010 5:24PM
Actually, the iPhone OS used to have a Soulseek P2P client back in the days of 1.x.x (around 2008 or so): http://torrentfreak.com/islsk-brings-file-sharing-to-iphone-080515/