Sebastian Thrun: Google's Driverless Car
Tumblr 101: Tips And Tricks To Get Started
Bill Gates, Jerry Seinfeld ad airs - Apple has nothing to worry about
Jerry Seinfeld, famous for developing a popular TV show "about nothing," seems to be at it again. Except this time he's part of a $300 million advertising campaign for Microsoft that also seems to be about nothing. And while nothing might be kind of funny in 22 minute segments that are always about something at their core, the first Microsoft commercial starring Bill Gates and Jerry Seinfeld really does seem to be about nothing. In that pointless, mind-boggling, "what the hell are they trying to say?" kind of way.
It would probably be bearable if the 90 second commercial were at least funny. But really, it's not. The point is apparently to introduce the audience to the characters and the funny will come in later ads. Presumably so will information about Vista. But seriously. 90 seconds of nothing? The very first Mac vs. PC ad weighed in at around 30 seconds, was funny, and didn't require much setup. If this is the best Microsoft's ad team has to offer, Apple doesn't have much to worry about.
On the other hand, while Apple continues to gain popularity, Microsoft still dwarfs the company in terms of market share. So maybe Microsoft doesn't really need to follow the format set by others.
It would probably be bearable if the 90 second commercial were at least funny. But really, it's not. The point is apparently to introduce the audience to the characters and the funny will come in later ads. Presumably so will information about Vista. But seriously. 90 seconds of nothing? The very first Mac vs. PC ad weighed in at around 30 seconds, was funny, and didn't require much setup. If this is the best Microsoft's ad team has to offer, Apple doesn't have much to worry about.
On the other hand, while Apple continues to gain popularity, Microsoft still dwarfs the company in terms of market share. So maybe Microsoft doesn't really need to follow the format set by others.
Comments
38
Subscribe to commentsToddSep 5th 2008 9:17AM
The commercial is a perfect representation of Microsoft;
1 - Fails to innovate, just [ poorly ] mimics other people's creativity and ingenuity.
2 - Fails to function in its intended purpose ( humor, raise brand awareness )
3 - Takes three times longer than the competition to complete ( 90 seconds, vs. "I'm a Mac" 30 seconds ).
What's the problem?
MaccaSep 5th 2008 12:19PM
1 - Fails to innovate, just [ poorly ] mimics other people's creativity and ingenuity.
And apples ads didn't? Are any advertisements or artworks of any kind not taken from the ideas of others?
MaccaSep 5th 2008 9:20AM
Good god...
This website has really gone to a new low of Mac worship.
Brad LinderSep 5th 2008 9:23AM
So you're saying you liked the ad or found it funny? Because seriously, I read a dozen or so reviews of this ad on other sites before writing this post and not a single one thought it was good.
Also, FYI, I don't own a Mac and rarely use one for work.
MaccaSep 5th 2008 8:48PM
Sounds like you base your opinion on what everyone else says, and not the way you see it yourself.
Also, know one cares what operating system you use.
DiRTSep 5th 2008 12:50PM
I agree with him Brad. You're simply wrong. The commercial was awesome. Lots of "other places" will say it isn't funny too. They also suck at Apple's teet.
noirsSep 5th 2008 9:33AM
It's funny.
raccoSep 5th 2008 9:41AM
funniest part was Bill using his police mug shot on the clown club id card
http://digg.com/microsoft/Bill_Gates_uses_police_mug_shot_in_the_Seinfeld_M_ad
Halo2MasterSep 5th 2008 9:41AM
I guess I am in the minority here, but I found it at least as entertaining and humorous as any of the Mac vs PC ads.
Gates seemed stiff and awkward, but Seinfeld was being Seinfeld.
Not saying I loved it (after all, it is a commercial), but the Mac vs PC ads are nothing spectacular either.
Scott FranklinSep 8th 2008 9:07AM
I don't think you are in the minority. I think it is a vocal minority that seems to be in the wrong. It was very funny and snarky mac addicts are blinded by their oversized egos.
JeffSep 5th 2008 11:54AM
That was hilarious. Maybe about nothing, but I thought it was classic.
MarkSep 5th 2008 12:14PM
Roger Ebert says you can't argue about funny. Either you laugh or you don't. I laughed.
That doesn't mean the ads are not a mistake. I'm doubtful they will do what Microsoft wants them to do.
But what do I know? I hate the Mac/PC ads, and they seem to be working.
Marc CraccoSep 5th 2008 11:17AM
I thought this site was dedicated to downloads. I in no way see how an article about a microsoft commercial belongs here. While we're at it why the author of the article presumes to know all that this GROUP of commercials will amount to (especially since this is only one of many) and states that Apple has nothing to worry about.
ToddSep 5th 2008 11:50AM
I consider this post to be a helpful public service, very much in the context of downloading software.
You may use your experience with the Microsoft advertisement ( fails to convey any meaning or purpose, performs poorly in its intended function, etc. ) as a way to set your expectation when you download and use Microsoft software.
DiRTSep 5th 2008 12:51PM
STFU Todd. That's was great. Much better than the "It just works in OSX" adds that really only mean "It just works as long as we have our own version of the program you are looking for which nine out of ten times, we don't."
kingabraham3Sep 5th 2008 11:49AM
its called speculation. and it so happens that I, as a reader, give a reasonable amount of credence to the author's speculatory comments.
FrancisSep 5th 2008 11:50AM
I have to disagree with the author on this one. I saw the commercial a few times last night and while after the first viewing I was more awed than anything else, repeated viewings only got funnier to me. The sheer absurdity and randomness really fits my style of humor and while it didn't actually advertise anything, I still thought it was a great commercial. Definitely a great step forward for Microsoft's ad-machine and almost as successful as those Microsoft Mohave commercials they have been running lately.
Also, shame on you for referring to Apple's PC vs Mac commercials as funny. Those are just horrible. They make me want to throw my Iphone at the TV.
(well that and the app crashes and lousy 3G connection)
mike k.Sep 5th 2008 12:51PM
MS has potential, but that commerical was far too long and mostly confusing. Apple's ads are tongue in cheek and very obvious as to what they're getting it.
MS doesn't need to mirror the apple ads but they definitely need to have more of a punch line than seinfeld saying silly things that have nothing to do with the product.
NathanSep 5th 2008 12:51PM
If it were not for that last paragraph in the article, I would officially remove the RSS feed for this site from My Yahoo! The commercial was mildly funny if not random. It does have a message about Windows in it too. It is saying that in the near future, Windows (7) will be more user friendly and such. Kind of like Macs.
ToddSep 5th 2008 12:43PM
"[ the commercial ] is saying that in the near future, Windows (7) will be more user friendly and such. Kind of like Macs."
Yes! That was the point of my first comment!