Copyright Royalty Board raises rates: internet radio stations cry foul
Bill and Rebecca Goldsmith, who run Radio Paradise, have started a new blog, with a detailed explanation of the impact the new rates would have on small webcasters. While both internet and traditional radio stations pay royalties to artists and songwriters, only online webcasters have to pay royalties to copyright holders. That's because Congress bought the argument that streaming audio is no different from MP3 downloads, in that both make high quality digital audio available to users who can then save copies on their computer.
Of course, you could also record broadcast radio onto a cassette or CD if you have the equipment. And while it's not that difficult to find software allowing you to save internet broadcasts, the product you wind up with typically isn't nearly as good as what you'd get from iTunes or BitTorrent. The songs run into one another; may or may not include metadata; you don't get full albums.
At the very least, internet and terrestrial broadcast radio stations should be subjected to the same fees. But the truth is that while companies like Clear Channel could easily afford the new fees, small stations like Radio Paradise cannot. And I think the world needs small non-commercial stations to broadcast music that might be hard to come by otherwise. Something copyright holders have never seemed to understand is that internet radio serves the same promotional purpose as broadcast radio. If you hear a song you like, perhaps you'll go out and buy it.